Newsletter - January 7, 2002
2002 – YEAR OF HOPE, OR GLORY?
In this opinion
piece Melvin Gold, Managing Director
PKF Hotel Consultancy
Services (UK) and PKF Partner, looks at the prospect for the hotel
industry in the coming year.
For the hotel industry,
2001 was a year which
we always felt was going to be difficult. The heady days of the millennium
proved to be a catalyst for an exuberant level of performance across the
continent’s hotel industry, almost without exception. Given that, we
felt that a hangover was likely to be a consequence. But it was to be
worse than that as the industry met with a series of accidents on the way
home from the party.
At the start of 2001
all the talk was of the downturn in the US economy. How deep was it? How
long would it last? How far would it spread? And
while the talk went on the travelling slowed down. While cities
were worrying about economic downturn creeping in from the USA, rural
areas of the UK suddenly found a far bigger threat in their midst – foot
and mouth disease. There was some spread to the continent but this was
limited. However, the television images spread the story far and wide and
much more quickly than the disease itself had ever threatened to do. The
fallout was felt by the tourism industry, perhaps to an even greater
extent than the agricultural community.
Then, having weathered
a quite difficult summer season for tourism (especially in the UK), an
event took place that was to put all previous difficulties into the shade.
11 September 2001 is a date that will be branded into the annals of
history forevermore. The horrific pictures from New York challenged the
psyche of every right thinking human being. It did not take long for those
connected with the tourism industry to realise that images of aeroplanes
being flown into buildings would shake the confidence of the air traveller
for some time to come and change the traditional paradigms of the tourism
industry, probably forever.
September’s figures
for the industry in key gateway cities were awful. October’s were worse,
including a 34.1% rooms yield decline in London, the worst single-month
deterioration ever recorded by our 29-year-old survey. While average rate
in the British capital fell by a similar amount in November, around 15%,
the drop in occupancy was less severe – some consolation, but still
enough to put most hoteliers off their Christmas pudding.
So basically that’s
where we are today. The big question is, what happens next?
This time last year we
expected 2002 to be a better year than 2001. The economic forecasts showed
improved growth in many European countries, while a wide range of events
promised a boost to tourism, not least in the UK with the queen’s Golden
Jubilee and the Commonwealth Games in Manchester. But 2002’s party looks
like being spoiled by the events of 2001.
In the UK, the
queen’s Silver Jubilee in 1977 was one of the most-successful years for
tourism. The pomp and pageantry proved a perfect magnet for attracting our
cousins from across the Atlantic. The way things feel right now there is
no magnet yet invented that can help gold emulate silver, and the
Commonwealth Games is also set to be a more-subdued occasion. However, we
should not despair entirely.
The Afghanistan
situation appears to be drawing to a close, with the extremists and
terrorists routed. If that were the end of it then we may see Americans
(and others) travelling almost in celebration and undertaking previously
cancelled trips. I have to say that I am sceptical about this happening,
but some upturn is not impossible. Then there is the marketing money
available, not least that allocated to the British Tourist Authority in
the wake of foot and mouth and which, to my knowledge, has not so far been
spent.
Furthermore, the
UK’s situation is far from unique. Paris’s suffering is even deeper
than London’s, and Rome, Amsterdam, Madrid and other major gateway
cities are all experiencing uncomfortably low numbers. Tourism providers
have been hard-pressed in the final quarter of 2001 and the
supply–demand equation is sufficiently out of balance to ensure that
there are some attractive deals available, not just in hotels but also on
airlines, from car rental companies and at some major attractions.
Although this is not a pricing issue, low prices will not do any harm in
boosting visitor numbers. So we cannot rule out a really major push for
the American visitor if there is a glimmer of hope that such a campaign
may be successful. A period of calm is a prerequisite for such initiatives
and we may get this just in the nick of time.
Then there is the
economy. Or in fact the economies, since there are many separate ones that
have a bearing on the overall situation. America has been on the brink for
the whole of 2001 and 11 September just made things worse. Recently
Germany announced it was technically in recession. Japan has been swimming
against the tide for a long time, although it is a strong swimmer. No one
seems to be able to agree about the UK and no consensus has really
emerged. There seem to be more economists about at present who believe we
will avoid a recession than those of the contrary view, but then does
anyone really know? What we do know is that it is possible to broadly
correlate hotel industry performance against economic performance for long
periods of time. Therefore, once we get out of the shadow of terrorism,
the longer-term trend is likely to more-closely correlate with that of the
economies of key source markets and the country of domicile.
To compound this, in
12 continental European countries a brave new dawn arrives with the
introduction in January 2002 of the euro in a tangible form. Many
questions arise. Will people be tempted to travel across borders just
because it is easier to do so? Will there be logistical problems in the
distribution of currency that prove disruptive to eurozone countries in
early 2002? Will the level of increased spending late in 2001 to clear a
backlog of sometimes ‘black’ old currency reduce spending in eurozone
economies early in the new year? Will the eurozone countries have enough
economic instruments at their disposal to act in the interests of their
own economies in more difficult economic times than have been experienced
to date? These are all valid questions to which the answers are currently
unknown. I put them before you on a rhetorical basis. We will know the
answers soon enough. But the reality of the euro will be an event that
changes the face of Europe – let’s hope it’s for the best.
So let’s try and
pile all this information onto the scales and weigh up the balance of
fortune for the hotel industry in 2002. Hope or glory? I have one proviso
and two basic scenarios.
The proviso is that I
am assuming a period of calm will ensue in the ‘War against Terrorism’
– from all sides. The Israeli–Palestinian conflict will probably
continue – it is difficult to see an end in sight although we can but
hope – but we must believe that it will not spill over, either into a
cross-border regional conflict or into wider international terrorism.
Based on that proviso
the optimist in me can see a return to a flat or positive growth trend in
key gateway cities around May/June time, assuming that some marketing
takes place in long-haul markets this winter to give travellers impetus to
travel and that economic news is reasonably positive. Under this
optimistic scenario we are still unlikely to see a return to trading
levels even at 1999 levels until 2003 at the earliest.
The more pessimistic
scenario has it that recovery will not be evident until late 2002 or early
2003 and will take place at a slower pace. This scenario will most likely
follow on from poor economic performance, whether driven by the euro or
more traditional factors. This would have a heavier impact on domestic
markets and the wider hotel markets stretching well beyond the gateway
cities. In other words things will get worse before they get better. 1999
level performance would therefore not be seen until 2004, or later.
Forecasting is an
imprecise science at the best of times. I lay out the arguments and make
no apology on this occasion for a less than satisfactory conclusion. I
live in hope of an industry that will return to strong growth in both
supply and demand in the medium to longer term. I hope the more optimistic
of the above scenarios will come to pass. But in 2002 I suspect that glory
will not be a word associated with the hotel industry very often, so we
will have to rely on the queen, the athletes at the Commonwealth Games and
the successful introduction of the euro. Happy New Year.
Melvin Gold is
managing director of PKF's hotel consultancy services department and a PKF
partner. He rejoined PKF as a director in September 1996 having previously
been a senior consultant with the firm from 1989 to 1992.
PKF - Hotel
Consultancy Services
http://www.pkf.co.uk/
New Garden House - 78 Hatton Garden
United Kingdom - London EC1N 8JA
Phone: +44 (0)20 7831 7393
Fax: +44 (0)20 7404 8112
Email: hotels@uk.pkf.com
Source:
PKF – UK
SRS-WORLDHOTELS EXPANDS “PRIVATE
LABEL” SERVICES
SRS-WORLDHOTELS,
one of the world’s leading and most dynamic hotel marketing and
representation consortia, has announced that the German hotel group
Lindner Hotels AG will be marketed as a private label client effective
January 1, 2001. Lindner Hotels & Resorts is a group of ten city
hotels and seven resort hotels located throughout Germany and Switzerland.
Under
its private label services, SRS-WORLDHOTELS enables smaller and regional
hotel and resort chains such as Linder, Steigenberger Hotels & Resorts
and Asia’s Pan Pacific Hotels & Resorts, to take advantage of the
group’s extensive worldwide sales, marketing and reservations services
while at the same time maintaining a separate group brand identity and its
own tailor-made sales and marketing promotions within the group.
"SRS-WORLDHOTELS
is not only effective for individual hotels, but also for small hotel
groups who do not have their own international sales, marketing and
reservations infrastructure, " said Roland Jegge, Vice President
Asia/Pacific of SRS-WORLDHOTELS.
"They
can still have their own group identify and group sales and marketing
promotions, but at the same time take advantage of our global marketing
reach."
Currently,
SRS-WORLDHOTELS has more than 400 member hotels in its portfolio,
representing over 70,000 rooms in 65 countries and 250 destinations
worldwide. In 2000, SRS-WORLDHOTELS generated over 1.2 million room nights
for its members and a total turnover of US$192 million – an increase of
17% over the previous year.
SRS-WORDLHOTELS’
Asia/Pacific operation has grown dramatically to 20 staff in four offices
around the region. The company has over 50 properties in Asia/Pacific and
SRS-WORLDHOTELS saw an increase of over 40% in it room night production
from the Asia Pacific region in 2000.
Issued on behalf of SRS-WORLDHOTELS by Grebstad Hicks Communications.
For further information, please contact:
Grebstad Hicks Communications
SRS-WORLDHOTELS
Mr Paul Hicks Tel: 852 2810 0532 Mr
Roland Jegge Tel: 65 227 5535
paulh@ghc.com.hk
rjegge@srs-worldhotels.com
LODGING
EXECUTIVES SENTIMENT SLIPS BACK – ROBUST FEELING OF FUTURE RECOVERY HAS
WANED
Durham, N.H., Dec. 31, 2001 -- The current hospitality
industry sentiment has executives feeling ever so slightly better than the
previous four months about present conditions and still highly optimistic
about the future. According to the latest attitudes of lodging industry
executives, the Lodging Executives Sentiment Index (LEsI) slipped back to
50.0, flatlined in December, down slightly from November's reading of
54.7. With present conditions inching upward, to 14.7 in December from 9.4
in November, the decrease is attributable to the future situation index
reading of 85.3 down from 100.0 last month. This indicates that the robust
feeling of recovery has waned a bit among lodging executives. In contrast
the December ISM Non-Manufacturing Business Activity Index (formerly the
National Association of Purchasing Manager’s Index — NAPM) increased
by 2.9% in December to a level of 54.2%. This is the second straight month
that the index has been above 50%, indicating expansion in the general
economy, and a continued recovery for the services side of the US economy.
A LEsI reading of 50+ indicates that the lodging industry is generally
expanding; and below 50, the industry is generally declining. The distance
from 50 is indicative of the strength of the expansion or decline.
Separately,
the executives projected reservations over the next 12 months to a 67.6
Reservations Expectations Index reading in December versus a 73.5 November
reading compared to the last 12 months. 76% of the lodging executives
rated the current business as “bad,” with the same percentage, 76%,
expecting the business activity to be “about the same” in the next
twelve months.
The
Lodging Employment Index indicated a slight increase reading 53.1 from
50.0 last month, November. Now recording a year of history, for the
employment index lodging industry executives are asked whether, over the
next 12 months, do they expect to: 1) add non-management employees, 2)
keep the number about the same, or 3) reduce the total number of
non-management employees. The US labor market continued to weaken in
December with the jobless rate rising to 5.8% and employment shrinking by
124,000. However, the losses were smaller than expected and the worst is
likely behind us. While manufacturing continues to lose ground, services,
government and construction payrolls increased at the end of the year.
|
December
2001 Lodging Executives Sentiment
at a Glance
|
Indicator
|
Index
Reading
|
Direction
of Business Activity
|
Speed
of Change in Business Activity
|
|
LESI
|
50.0
|
Flatlined
|
Slower
|
|
Present Situation Index
|
14.7
|
Declining
|
Slower
|
|
Future Expectations Index
|
85.3
|
Expanding
|
Slower
|
|
Reservations Expectations Index
|
67.6
|
Expanding
|
Slower
|
|
Employment Expectations Index
|
53.1
|
Expanding
|
Very SI Faster
|
About
the Index
Following
the Institute of Supply Management’s Index method of tracking leading
indicators, the LEsI satisfies the need for real-time information for
executive decision making in the lodging industry. The LEsI is a leading
indicator based on opinions of lodging executives. The LEsI is a diffusion
index--a convenient summary measure showing the prevailing direction of
change and the magnitude of change for the Lodging Industry as expressed
by executives in the industry. The LEsI has reported a monthly index
reading for 56 consecutive months.
About
LodgingForecast
LodgingForecast
publishes several lodging related indicators each month. Using
proprietary forecasting models, researchers at LodgingForecast generate
the LEsI along with the Lodging Industry Barometer (LIB) and several other
indices each month
TAJ
GROUP TO SELL 7 HOTELS
The
Taj group of hotels, as part of a restructuring exercise, is planning to
sell seven out of its 60-odd hotel properties in India and overseas.
Confirming
the development, R K Krishna Kumar, managing director of Indian Hotels
said: “We feel there are some properties that do not quite fit the Taj
profile which we would eventually like to sell. In all, we have identified
seven such properties.”
However,
Krishna Kumar refused to divulge the names of the properties which are to
be put on the block.
He
added though that the City Inn —which it acquired along with Blue
Diamond in Pune —in Baramati, Maharashtra, was one of them.
According
to sources, the reason for selling these seven properties could be their
uneconomical size and lack of demand.
"These
seven hotel properties clearly are not up to the Taj standards and the
image the group was trying to create," Krishna Kumar added.
The
Taj group is India's largest hotel chain offering 56 hotels in 40
locations across South Asia and 6 hotels in other parts of the world.
It
operates in luxury, business and leisure categories. The luxury hotels
division is the largest with a turnover of Rs 451 crore.
Source:
Business Standard - India
THE EURO AND THAI TOURISM INDUSTRY
The
Thai tourism industry has welcomed the introduction of the euro, the new
European single currency, in anticipation that it will further boost
visitor arrivals from Europe to Thailand. According to Tourism Authority
of Thailand Governor Pradech Phayakvichien, the euro should help bring a
greater degree ofstability to financial relationships between tour
wholesalers, travel agents and buyers in Europe and Thai sellers like
hotels, tour operators and other tourism products. ?Global financial
instability and currency fluctuations are one of the biggest problems
facing the industry, especially for small- and medium-sized companies,?
the Governor said. ?The euro should make it easier for buyers and sellers
to do business and maintain prices.?
The impact of the euro on commercial and economic relations, including the
important travel & tourism sector, was discussed at a seminar at the
Thai Foreign Ministry on December 27, 2001.
Co-organised by the Economic Affairs Department of Foreign Ministry,
European Studies Centre of Chulalongkorn University and TAT, the seminar
featured presentations by the Director of Chulalongkorn University?s
Economic Research Centre Dr Chayodom Sappasri and Director-General of
Economic Affairs Department Mr Pradap Pibulsonggram, as well as Governor
Pradech.
As of January 1, 2002, the euro became legal tender in 12 European Union (EU)
member countries, namely Austria, Belgium, Finland, France, Germany,
Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Spain and Portugal. Three
other countries, the UK, Denmark and Sweden, have chosen not to join at
the moment.
Its introduction, replacing the old currencies like the lire, franc, etc.,
has been described as a turning point in the world?s financial history.
The eurozone countries, with a total population of more than 300 million,
are major generators of visitors for Thailand in terms of both arrivals
and foreign exchange revenue.
In 2000, Europe (including EU and non-EU member countries) was the second
biggest source region of visitors with a total of 2,168,996 arrivals in
2000, an increase of 8.97% over 1999. During January-October 2001,
European visitors totalled 1,682,612, up 7.16% over the same period of
2000.
In 2000, European visitors spent an average of 3,174.09 baht per person
per day (or US$79.13), contributing about 88.95 billion baht (or US$2.22
billion) foreign exchange revenue to the Thai
economy. That comprised 31.18% of total foreign exchange earnings, and the
second highest after earnings from Asian visitor arrivals.
The seminar at the Thai Foreign Ministry was designed to help participants
better understand the impact of the euro on Thai tourism-related
businesses.
Governor Pradech noted that development of both trade and tourism go hand
in hand, especially because strong economies lead to strong travel for
leisure, business and conventions/exhibitions.
?Trade within Europe accounts for an average of 20% of global trade. We
expect the euro to become an important world currency, similar to the
dollar. This will help Europe?s trade-partner countries and nearly all
industries including travel and tourism,? the Governor said.
According to TAT analysis, most Thai tour operators still quote their tour
price in US dollars or in local European currencies or directly in Thai
baht. This will change in future, as the operators will no longer have to
quote in several different European currencies.
Many websites also are expected to start quoting their prices in euros.
Within Europe, denominating prices in euros is expected to lower the cost
of goods and services by eliminating the costs of exchange conversions and
currency fluctuations which are estimated to account for between 0.5% to
1% of the EU?s GDP.
This will make it easier for companies to do business, increase consumer
purchasing power and boost intra-regional trade. The economies of the EU
are projected to enjoy a 2% growth rate in 2001 and a higher growth rate
after usage of the euro becomes commonplace.
The euro was initially inaugurated on January 2, 1999 and underwent a
three-year transition period to give time to banks and other businesses to
make the shift. The transition period ended on January 1, 2002, when the
new euro banknotes and coins were introduced throughout the eurozone.
Additional information on the euro can be downloaded from http://www.visiteurope.com/euro.htm
REED TRAVEL
EXHIBITIONS TO CREATE COMPREHENSIVE MICE DATABASE
Reed Travel
Exhibitions (RTE), organisers of EIBTM, AIME and the ICCA Exhibition, is
to pioneer the world's most comprehensive database of buyers and sellers
in the incentive, business travel and meetings industry. The unique
venture, which will be offered online at minimal cost, will help to
revolutionise an industry intent on capturing quality data for effective,
precision targeting. Investment for the project has already been approved
and discussions are now taking place with a number of leading database
software companies around the world.
Tom Nutley, Managing Director of RTE revealed news of the development,
which is expected to take two years to reach optimum levels of excellence.
We are good listeners at RTE and have based the success of our 22 years of
experience on face-to-face discussions with customers as well as studying
regular detailed market research with exhibitors and visitors. It is
important to have a deep knowledge and insight into our customers, their
processes and needs. ?We are therefore keenly aware of exactly what the
industry needs to help it consistently improve and grow. Our mission has
always to be customer driven and customer friendly.
"I have never promised anything that we could not deliver and I never
will. Knowledge is 'doing', not just 'being' and I want this to be a
valuable, practical application of a verified and constantly updated
information source for customer 365 days a year.
He emphasised that EIBTM would continue to work with third party
intermediaries to identify and recruit buyers. "We value their
goodwill and assistance enormously, "he said " and we will not
want to change these relationships which continue to develop and
grow."
Mr. Nutley said that one of the most important elements of such a huge
database is the quality of the information. Because RTE has 11 regional
and sector events throughout the world, the company will constantly
re-evaluate the quality of the information and its accuracy.
?This will allow sellers and buyers to easily identify better business
opportunities and because we already have three events tailored to the
international incentive, business travel and meetings industry spread
evenly throughout the year, we will be able to arrange appointments with
targeted contacts at our next event."
"This kind of knowledge-based investment would be cost prohibitive if
it was used for just one event. This is why RTE is able to offer a unique,
customer friendly service that goes far beyond the basics of an
exhibition.?He said that he had been thinking about an ultimate industry
database concept for two years. "I could only drive forward once I
was satisfied that the latest IT solution for a new and crucial one-stop,
paper-free business proposition was fully operational", he commented.
One-Stop 'Shop'
News of this latest move by EIBTM follows the successful two-year IT
development to offer a faster, effective and more efficient paper-free
solution to the often heavy burden of administration associated with the
build-up to a leading international industry event such as EIBTM.
Now exhibitors can register, book their flights and hotels, access and, if
necessary change their travel itinerary as well as make appointments and
view their appointments schedule - at the click of a computer
mouse."We had some problems with the new software for EIBTM 2001 but
these have been ironed out and improvements made to increase the speed,
simplicity and efficiency of the programme. "Time is the most
precious commodity for our clients and this development will now do much
to cut down on time and hassle.""Reed Travel Services (RTS),
with its instant access to a range of travel alternatives at preferential
prices, is another example of an investment that is only cost effective if
it is developed for the kind of wide portfolio of industry events
currently operated and owned by RTE," said Mr. Nutley.
Exhibitors and visitors can carry out all their requirements for EIBTM
2002 online, including:
*Booking exhibitor and non-hosted visitor hotels and flights via the newly
launched Reed Travel Services, offering competitive prices, instant
response and on-screen itineraries* Hosted Buyers being able to view their
own personal web page for full details of travel arrangements made on
their behalf* Buyers having the ability to change flights and book
additional accommodation* Request appointments* View pre-scheduled
appointments* Trade visitor pre-registration* Exhibitors can update their
product information and display press releasesPractical Customer Service
He cited EIBTM's SPOCS idea as typical of RTE's attention to detail and
customer service. "SPOC stands for Single Point of Contact, which
means that each exhibitor is provided with their own personal contact
during the busy build-up period and on site to ensure that their
participation is as problem-free as possible. "This is a concept that
we have successfully and uniquely tried and tested on other RTE events and
introduced to EIBTM 2001 for the first time. There is nothing more
annoying than be passed from one person to another, particularly when the
chips are down."The SPOCS are able to smooth away any problems and
act as a reassuring personal and dedicated contact from six weeks before
the event through to stand building at Palexpo."
*AIME 2002 will be held at Melbourne Convention and Exhibition Centre,
Melbourne, Australia 19-20 February and EIBTM 2002 at Palexpo, Geneva
21-23 May.
LONDON’S HOSPITALITY MANAGERS ‘WORK HARD AND PLAY HARD’
Hospitality industry
managers in London and the South-East work an average 50-60 hours a week
and the divorce rate among them is higher than the national average,
according to a survey.
A lifestyle
questionnaire carried out by recruitment agency Chess Partnership found
managers worked an average 11-hour day. Less than 1% of those questioned
worked fewer than 40 hours a week.
The rate of divorce or
separation was 33% among managers over the age of 30, just above the
national average. The rate among men (43%) was higher than that among
women (28%).
But Chess managing
director Chris Sheppardson did not think the above-average divorce rate
was related to the long hours worked.
"Most managers in
most businesses work about 50-60 hours. I was actually quite encouraged by
the figure. It is comparable with other professions."
Sheppardson thought
the divorce rate was rather related to the pressures of the job. "It
is a very stressful business, but even then the divorce figure is very
close to the national average."
There was better news
on the salary front. More than a third (36%) of hospitality managers over
the age of 30 were earning in excess of £40,000 a year.
More than 60% of those
over 30 owned their own homes.
Further findings
revealed the Daily Mail as the most popular newspaper among
female managers, while men preferred The Daily Telegraph or The
Times.
Male managers said Caterer
& Hotelkeeper was their favourite magazine, while females
preferred lifestyle and travel titles.
Dining out was the
favourite pastime, although fine-dining restaurants were only popular with
those over 40. Only 7% of managers aged 18-39 cited fine-dining
restaurants as their first choice when eating out. Italian food was the
most popular.
Wine was the most
popular alcoholic drink and 63% of respondents were non-smokers. Most
people enjoyed two or three holidays a year.
Watching and playing
sports was a favoured pastime for males, and also for females under 40.
Said Sheppardson:
"What we're seeing is a new generation of managers coming through.
They are more sporty and more health conscious."
Chess polled more than
340 managers from the hospitality industry who had attended interviews
with the agency. Of those completing the questionnaire, 24% worked in
hotels, 27% in restaurants, 29% in contract catering and the remaining 20%
in related sectors.
Source: Caterer & Hotelkeeper
magazine, 3-9 January 2002 www.caterer.com
Chess Partnership www.chess-partnership.com/
|