Newsletter - October 30, 2002
Horst
Schulze Believes He Can Do It Again
with a
New Luxury Hotel Chain
Inside an office on West Paces Ferry Road, one of the country's
best-known hoteliers is quietly planning a new luxury chain.
Horst
Schulze, the longtime president of the Ritz-Carlton until he resigned
nearly two years ago, has assembled a group from the old days. They are
working out of the offices of W.B. Johnson, who owned the Ritz-Carlton
from 1983 to 1998 and grew it into a worldwide chain.
Johnson
possibly will participate in the new venture, said Schulze, who is still
in the research phase and will decide by May whether to move forward.
Schulze,
who said he'd like to start in Atlanta, confirmed that he has discussed
developing at the Buckhead Plaza site near his office on West Peachtree,
though he also has looked at many other sites around the world.
Schulze
has not yet assembled financial partners, he said. Experts say funding for
hotels is tough to find in today's economy, though Schulze's track record
would help.
Several
luxury hotel chains, including Ritz-Carlton, Four Seasons, Mandarin
Oriental and St. Regis, are expanding in the United States, despite the
down economy.
"I
think Mr. Schulze would be well-received by any potential partners,
because he has a legendary record in the industry," said Bruce Ford,
vice president of sales at Lodging Econometrics in Portsmouth, N.H.
Mark
Woodworth at PKF Consulting in Atlanta said "patient capital"
typically goes into high-end hotel projects, meaning investors are willing
to wait longer to see the return on investment.
Schulze
"is such a proven individual in the industry, and he has demonstrated
over a long time that he knows how to create a product," Woodworth
said.
Atlanta
developer W.B. Johnson bought the famous Boston Ritz-Carlton and the
naming rights in 1983. Johnson, who got rich as a Waffle House and Holiday
Inn franchisee, expanded the Ritz name around the world. By the early
1990s, there were 25 Ritz-Carltons.
Johnson
owned some properties and managed the rest. Schulze was president of the
management company.
The
company did have troubles, including lawsuits from hotel owners. A suit
filed by four owners in 1995 called the company "the most arrogant
and financially irresponsible hotel company in the world."
However,
Ritz-Carlton also achieved a reputation for unparalleled service. In 1992,
it became the first hotel chain to win the prestigious Malcolm Baldrige
National Quality Award for service.
Johnson
sold the company to Marriott. Ritz has continued to expand and is moving
its headquarters from Atlanta to the Washington area, where Marriott is
based. Critics say that Ritz has lost some of its cachet since Marriott
took over.
Several
old colleagues, including Bob Warman, previously vice president of
operations at the Ritz, are working with Schulze on the concept.
For
now, the new company is called West Paces Hotel Group, after the
headquarters address. Schulze is testing a few names for the hotels, he
said.
In
an interview, Schulze was vague about his vision. He said the hotels
likely will be smaller than a typical luxury hotel. However, they will not
be boutiques. He said he will use better efficiencies to increase profits
without cutting service.
"The
fast way is to walk into the hotel and eliminate the flowers," he
said. "Any idiot can do that."
The
hotels likely will be built from the ground up, because customers want a
new design, he said.
"There
is the potential to write a new book on our industry," he said.
"We think we did it right once. We think we can do it dramatically
better."
Marriott
to give $6 mln refund to hotel owners-WSJ
(Reuters) - Marriott International Inc.
will distribute an additional $6 million in purchasing rebates to the
owners of hotels it manages, the Wall Street Journal reported in its
online edition on Monday.
The unexpected payment comes after the hotelier
finally closed the books for years 2000 and 2001 on its former purchasing
unit, Marketplace by Marriott, the newspaper said.
The rebates are part of a dispute between
Marriott and some of its hotel-owner clients, who say the firm has been
unfairly profiting from purchasing services at the hotel owners' expense,
the Journal said.
Marriott denies those allegations and says it
passes along to the owners any rebates that it receives from suppliers.
The Washington, D.C. hotelier disclosed two
weeks ago that it returned $8 million in certain purchasing rebates to
owners last year, as well as a further $20 million in rebates for
telecommunication services and $20 million in joint-marketing allowances
for marketing programs with companies such as American Express Co (nyse: AXP
- news
- people).
and Visa International, the Journal said.
Owner
Claims Four Seasons Staff Freeloaded
$180,000
in Services at Caracas Four Seasons;
Fierce
Legal Battle Continues, $120 million
Hotel
Remains Closed
In
July, 18 months after opening, the Four Seasons hotel in Caracas was shut
down.
Before
the mudslinging, before the shouting, the Four Seasons hotel in Caracas
was the toast of the town.
It rose 21 stories high out
of the upscale Altamira neighborhood, a marriage of luxury and modernity
with an unmatched pedigree: Four Seasons' first South American hotel.
Travel writers gushed, architecture mavens crowed, the developers rubbed
their hands with glee. Then the trouble began.
Today,
the hotel's owner, Consorcio Barr, and manager, Four Seasons Hotels and
Resorts, are waging a fierce legal battle that spans Caracas to Miami.
Consorcio
Barr, which is based in Caracas, has accused Four Seasons of financial
mismanagement and freeloading, allegations that have been dragged through
the media and five Venezuelan courts. In U.S. District Court in Miami, the
hotel giant accused Consorcio Barr of hacking into the Four Seasons
computer system. In July, 18 months after opening, the hotel was shut
down.
Says
Carlos Barrera, CEO of Consorcio Barr: "This is a powerful
corporation with a team of lawyers abusing the justice system and using it
to intimidate and harass."
Says
Katie Taylor, Four Seasons' president of worldwide business operations:
"Quite frankly, in the past four decades we have never had an
experience such as the one we are dealing with in Caracas."
Says
Chase Burritt, a hospitality analyst with Ernst & Young: "In a
down hotel economy, the whole owner-manager issue is a struggle. A mighty,
mighty struggle."
Carlos
Barrera and his brother, Lautaro, had long dreamed of building a luxury
hotel in the heart of Caracas, and Four Seasons, the Toronto-based hotel
management chain, was eager to open its first South American property.
Developer and hotelier clinched the deal in 1997.
Four
years later, in January 2001, the $120 million hotel, designed in part by
the Miami firm Arquitectonica, opened its doors.
Even
as travel writers were penning their accolades -- "room highlights
are heavenly" Condé Nast Traveler enthused -- tensions were afoot.
Four
Seasons felt rushed into opening; the hotel, they said, was incomplete.
They
agreed to a gradual, 'soft' opening after Consorcio Barr gave assurances
that they would cover start-up and operation costs, promises that Four
Seasons said were not kept.
"In
retrospect," said Taylor, "It is clear that Consorcio Barr's
inability to meet these commitments stemmed from the simple fact that they
did not have the financial resources necessary to do so."
The
Barreras' background is in general contracting. Their company, GYCSA, was
involved in the construction of the Eurobuilding Hotel in Caracas and the
city's subway system. Four Seasons in Caracas is their first hotel. They
are not connected with the Four Seasons condo/hotel in Miami, which is
scheduled to open next year.
Barrera,
for his part, said the Four Seasons ignored repeated requests, sent out
between January and April 2001, to submit financial reports to his
company. When the Barreras did receive reports, they were aghast.
Between
January and May 2001, Carlos Barrera said the staff freeloaded $180,000 in
services; one staffer racked up $5,000 in expenses in one month, he said,
and a pastry chef expensed $16,000 over four months, much of it at the
hotel bar.
"The
cost of the food, the beverages and the cleaning chemicals were not
acceptable by industry standards," Barrera said. "In some cases,
the cost of an item of food was higher than the selling price." Four
Seasons said their spending was in line with any luxury hotel's start-up
costs, and that their accounting was transparent. But Consorcio Barr, they
said, was snooping.
On
Nov. 6, 2001, Four Seasons filed a suit in U.S. District Court in Miami
accusing Consorcio Barr of hacking into its servers and accessing
proprietary information.
Four
Seasons was granted an injunction forbidding Consorcio Barr from
attempting to access Four Seasons network. Consorcio Barr, while decrying
the charges as false, said they were entitled to the information anyway.
Later,
their Miami lawyer, Eddie Palmer of Steel, Hector & Davis, unearthed
evidence that the Four Season's supposed computer expert witness had
fabricated his credentials.
Back
in Venezuela, the crisis grew.
On
Dec. 1, 2001, Four Seasons seized financial management of the hotel.
Consorcio Barr had been diverting money away from the hotel to pay other
expenses, they said, and food suppliers were not getting their money.
"Our
management agreement stipulates that if the owner of the hotel cannot
provide the proper working capital, Four Seasons has the right to assume
control of the hotel's revenue," Taylor said.
The
seizure was illegal, the Barreras said, and moreover Four Seasons failed
to meet its promise of yielding a net profit of $4 million over the first
year.
They
took Four Seasons to five courts in Venezuela, and obtained rulings saying
Four Seasons had to relinquish financial control of the hotel.
Four
Seasons appealed, and in June of this year, stopped taking reservations.
The litigation had disrupted their cash flow, Taylor said, making it
impossible to buy the staples necessary for running the hotel.
Weeks
later, the hotel sat vacant. Some 300 employees, locked out and unpaid,
staged protests widely covered in the Venezuelan media.
According
to hospitality industry watchers, money battles between hotel managers and
owners are not uncommon, especially in depressed times. Squeezed by their
lenders and facing a revenue drought, owners often accuse their managers
of cost overruns. One of the majors, Marriott International, is fending of
at least four lawsuits from owners charging it with mismanagement and
racketeering.
"Most
of the times the operator is not taking advantage, they are only doing
what is included in the contract," said Ernst & Young's Burritt.
"The operator really doesn't have an agenda. They make money when the
revenue is in."
But
Consorcio Barr's position is that Four Seasons is trying to
"financially asphyxiate" them. The owners are also indebted $41
million on the $120 million property, which includes shops and condos, and
their creditors are demanding payment on the now-empty hotel.
'Certainly
in a better economic environment, perhaps (the Four Seasons') poor
administration would have been less visible," the company said in an
e-mail to The Herald, '(But) the hotel problems are mainly due to the
operators' poor administration."
Barrera
said he is committed to reopening the hotel with a new management team.
Four Seasons, however, is digging in its heels.
"Four
Seasons has no desire to leave Caracas . . . we have expended millions of
dollars to help ensure the long-term success," Taylor said. "We
want to stay." In Venezuela, several decisions are pending, and in
Miami both sides are in arbitration. Neither side plans to take the gloves
off.
"Everybody's
had this trouble," Burritt said. "The only difference here is
that it's a lot more public."
Many
Hotels Are Turning to Fancy Spa Services to Stand Out
New York Times -
It is called the "morning jump
start" and is designed for jet-lagged guests who have to clear their
minds for negotiating deals. Here is what you get at the Hotel
Inter-Continental in Hong Kong: a dry-skin brushing to stimulate
circulation, the application of a spearmint-scented exfoliating body
polish to remove the dead skin cells, an aromatherapy body massage, a
luxury aromatherapy facial and, finally, a "stimulating" foot
massage.
Pretty
much every high-end hotel these days has rooms with multiline phones and
high-speed Internet access and a business center with fax machines and
conference tables. How, then, to lure business travelers in a soft market?
Spas
are the thing.
Not
so long ago, hotels that catered to corporate travelers offered up fairly
basic fare in the way of body and health care: a gym with a treadmill,
stationary bicycle and weights, and a beauty parlor (or hair dryer
attached to the bathroom mirror in less upscale lodgings).
That
is not good enough anymore. These days, a spa — a unisex
"wellness" center that offer as many as a dozen varieties of
facial treatments, body scrubs and massages — has become a way for
hotels to stand out. As often as not, it is connected to a fitness
emporium with exercise equipment ranging from Stairmaster machines to
lateral pulldowns. "Hotels are looking to ways to differentiate
themselves from one another in this competitive market," said
Stefanie Michaels, president of Adventuregirl.com, a travel Web site.
"Business travelers are weary and looking for ways to be at the top
of their game."
Of
course, it can be hard to stand out if everybody is doing the same thing.
The
growth in the number of "noteworthy hotel spas" has been
exponential, from 14 in 1995 to 35 in 2001 to ubiquitous today, according
to Tim Zagat, publisher of the Zagat Survey guidebooks. Since last year,
"almost every major hotel has built them," he said. "There
are a very large number of people who can't go more than two days without
going to a health club."
What
is striking about the phenomenon is the packaging. Before, hotels
generally had barbershops, beauty salons and fitness centers, and they
hired outside massage therapists. "But then, they packaged it all
together," Mr. Zagat said. "It's about the whole
experience."
Acknowledging
the trend, Zagat last year added a new category, "spa
facilities," to its Zagat Hotel Survey guides.
There
has been no letup in the movement, either. "In the last couple of
weeks, we've had four proposals out to hotels looking for spa and fitness
management, more than we've had for a while," said Liz Neporent,
creative director of Plus One Holdings, which creates corporate and hotel
fitness centers and spas nationwide. Clients have included the
Waldorf-Astoria, the Plaza Hotel and the Trump International Hotel and
Towers in New York. Increasingly, she said, business travelers "are
making choices based on whether they can get a facial and a massage at the
hotel."
Hyatt
says it has taken its spa services so seriously that it has introduced the
Spa Hyatt division to answer the growing demand for spa facilities by both
business and leisure travelers. Next year at the Grand Hyatt Hong Kong, an
entire floor of standard rooms will be converted into a spa floor, where
guests can actually spend the night in the spa.
The
Hotel Inter-Continental in Hong Kong also features jet-lag relief and
stress-buster treatments that it says are geared toward international
business travelers, about half of whom are based in the United States. One
of the most popular is the morning jump start. Then there is the
"good night, sleep tight" Chinese herbal wrap in which, after an
aromatherapy massage and exfoliation treatment, the body is enfolded in a
cloth drenched with herbs that are absorbed into the skin. While all that
is going on, the weary traveler gets a scalp massage.
Many
luxury hotels are upgrading existing spas. The Four Seasons Chicago, for
example, added five treatment rooms and a relaxation lounge to its fitness
facilities. The hotel will also now dispatch massage therapists at $120 a
therapist an hour to its conference rooms to do hand massages, chair
massages and reflexology treatments for executives as they negotiate
deals.
Jayne
Wagner, an advertising sales representative for Reader's Digest
Publications in Chicago, says her department schedules two or three
"spa events" annually at the Four Seasons for anywhere from 5 to
15 mostly female clients, as a counterpoint to male-dominated golf
outings. As the women wait for manicures, pedicures, massages and facials
in a "gathering room," she said, Reader's Digest executives talk
business with them.
The
Four Seasons New York is also redoing its 10-year-old spa. "A lot of
the plans we're doing focus on understanding that you've got guests for a
shorter period of time, and they require a speedier rejuvenation and
bounce-back," said Leslie Lefkowitz, a hotel spokeswoman.
That's
the way it goes at the 35,000-square-foot (that's almost an acre)
Peninsula Spa at the Peninsula Hotel in Manhattan, whose guests are mostly
business people. Maryanne Nielsen, the spa's general manager, says she
books a lot of groups from financial services companies like J. P. Morgan
and Credit Suisse First Boston that bring their clients for spa
treatments. "It allows their brain to recharge and relax so they
become more creative," she said.
Some
hotels are extending the spa concept right into the rooms. At the Cape
Grace, in Cape Town, South Africa, guests can summon a masseuse for
in-room full-body aromatherapy massage, reflexology treatments, sports
massage or a manicure-pedicure.
At
the new Hilton São Paulo Morumbi in the financial district of São Paulo,
Brazil, you can reserve one of eight "relaxation rooms" for $545
in peak season, almost triple the $189 price for most rooms, that are are
divided into three zones: work, relaxation and bath.
To
make sure they have it just right, many resorts are hiring seasoned
directors from destination spas. Marriott's Harbor Beach Resort and Spa in
Fort Lauderdale, Fla., for example, added an $8 million,
24,000-square-foot spa last year and hired the former spa director at
Canyon Ranch in Arizona to run it.
Marco
Beach Ocean Resort, in Marco Island, Fla., a favorite destination of many
event planners, often sees groups of executives who are there to mix
business with pleasure. The hotel recently created an 8,000-square-foot
spa.
"We
always choose a resort that has a spa and golf," said Michelle
Massey, travel coordinator for AIG Annuity Financial Institutions Group in
Houston.
Thailand
forms Convention and Exhibition Bureau
TravelWeekyAsia.com
- After several
delays, the Thailand convention bureau is now formally established.
Known
as Convention and Exhibition Bureau and launched late last month, it will
act as a one-stop service center and coordinate with Thai public and
private agencies to market the destination as a world-class venue.
The
bureau is now working on selecting a 11-member Board of Directors whose
first task would be to appoint an executive director to the bureau.
The
person tasked with putting together the body is Tourism Authority of
Thailand’s International Convention Division director Udon
Metatamrongsiri.
“We
need to have the first temporary board board meeting to select the
permanent board. Right now there is only one staff and I am the one,”
said Udon, who declined to say if he would take up the executive director
post.
The CEB has 90 days
from September 27 to do this. It’s expected to have about 30 staff and
Udon said he has budget of 130 million bath (US$3 million) right now.
UK:
Incoming visitor figures up for first time
Caterer.com
- The number of
overseas visitors to the UK has entered positive territory for the first
time this year, according to the latest survey.
Figures from the British Incoming Tour Operators Association
(BITOA) show visitor arrivals for September up by 3.71% on the same period
last year.
But figures are still some way off September 2000 numbers,
the last “normal” year for inbound tourism to Britain. Comparing
September 2002 with 2000, visitor arrivals are down by 20%.
September 2001 also showed a massive 23.62% decline on the
same period the previous year.
BITOA said the figures were “going in the right
direction” and that “2003 could be more healthy than was first
feared.”
In the first nine months of the year the number of arrivals
was down by 2.94% on the same period in 2001.
US
Securities Markets- An Investment Opportunity In Hotels For Institutional
Investors?
Written
By: Michael T. Sullivan &
Marshall
A. Bendelac
HVS Capital Corp
With
the uncertainty in US Securities markets, many institutional investors
have looked more favorably on real estate as an investment.
Representing hard assets, which theoretically have solid intrinsic values,
there has been a recent flight to this investment class due to its
long-term tangibility. Such investments are often more favorable
than some alternative speculative investments, such as companies bearing
few, if any, hard assets (i.e., “dot-coms”).
Real
estate’s limiting factor, however, is typically the percentage of the
total investment amount that most large institutional investors will
allocate to this asset class. Most investors will try to limit
their real estate (and real estate mortgage) portfolios to roughly 10% to
15% of their total assets, with the balance of their investment portfolios
typically deployed in the securities markets. Of this real estate
allocation, hotels or hospitality-oriented investments usually do not
exceed 20%. Additionally, as the values of their securities
portfolios drop in the present equity markets, the percentage of capital
that could otherwise be allocated to real estate is diminished.
Enticing
investors to put their capital in the real estate (and subsequently,
hospitality real estate) market, however, is the fact that the recent and
prolonged downturn in the US securities markets bears only an indirect
correlation to real estate asset valuation. Real estate values, in
general, are derived and fluctuate independently of securities prices.
However, an interesting exception to this exists, and can be found within
domestic hotel-oriented Real Estate Investment Trusts (REITs). These
are publicly-held companies that are essentially comprised of individual
and/or portfolio hotel assets, which trade on the US securities markets.
Examples include Host Marriott, Fel-Cor, and Equity Inns.
Presently
there are 15 hotel REITs which are traded on US stock exchanges. Furthermore,
several of them have been recently trading at significant discounts to
their Net Asset Values (NAVs), due to the depressed state of the equity
markets. Recent NAV discounts for several of these companies have
ranged from approximately 10%-60%. Essentially, this demonstrates
that the companies’ share prices are lower than the values (on a per
share basis) of the hotel investments which they hold. In other
words, hotels owned by REITs are worth more outside of the REIT than they
are as a holding of the REIT. As such, the sub-par performance in
the public equity markets presents savvy investors, who can analyze and
determine which of the public hotel REITs offers the quickest upside, with
an opportunity to capitalize on recovery in share prices that merely
reflects the true values of the underlying assets held in REITs.
Michael T. Sullivan
Marshall A. Bendelac
HVS Capital Corp.
1777 South Harrison St.
Denver, CO 80210
303-758-3100
303-691-3799 FAX
Rooms channel marketing - what
are your options?
The current reservation channel
options are too complex for hotels to manage by themselves. So many hotel
operators have voiced that quote in the past year it has become an
industry cliché.
Reservation channels, their options
and pricing plans are multiplying and changing so fast that a new species
of reservation marketing company has evolved to handle the shifting
environment. Often called 'representation companies' or 'reservation
service providers,' these new firms offer more than a means of access to
the thousands of channels; they are providing marketing services to
educate hoteliers about the new selling environment and working hard to
help them sell more rooms.
Many hoteliers are uncertain about
exactly what a 'net-rate' sales agreement is, or the 'merchant model' of
inventory control, or the difference between 'production' and
'consumption' fees. To make the reservation channel industry and its fees,
service options and technology more understandable we have interviewed
leaders from eight representation companies, both large and small, for a
fast class in how to sell rooms in the Digital Age.
Inventory control, the
'merchant model' and fees
Today technology has given us so
many ways to sell a room that it is nearly impossible for a hotel operator
to understand, let alone intelligently manage, the available channels for
room sales. There is the central reservation call center, now called a
'voice center;' the property itself, the 'big four' global distribution
companies (GDS), Amadeus, Sabre, Worldspan, and Galileo; additionally
there are thousands of private label Web sites like Expedia and Orbitz, as
well as hundreds of tour operators, corporate booking portals, and
regional convention coordinators. If you are the average hotel, many of
these channels have an allotment of your rooms, and it is likely most are
showing out of date rates and incorrect availability.
Communicating with all of these
channels to keep them current on inventory and rate requires, in some
cases, daily manual intervention with multiple faxes and phone calls. More
importantly, verifying the accuracy of each channel's current allotment
and rate by the property is critical but rarely automated. Most times
hotel operators do not know where or how their rooms are being sold or at
what rate.
In the United States Internet-booked
rooms is the fastest-growing segment of hotel reservations. Voice centers
(formerly known as 'central reservation offices') have seen their domestic
production shrinking steadily in the past three years, but internationally
and especially in Asia, voice centers continue to be strong reservation
providers. "Our voice center is not our biggest reservation producer,
but our voice services have grown in the past two years because we have
picked up Asian chain business," explained Rita Emmer, vice president
of VIP International (www.vipintcorp.com). "Regal Hotels, one of our
chain clients, has us manage phone reservations for their Japanese hotels
during Japanese business hours. Some chains, like Candlewood, have turned
over 100 percent of their new business voice reservations to VIP; others
use our voice center for early or late reservation calls. We provide a
single point of contact for reservation marketing to hundreds of channels
for our clients. We work with all the GDSes, and we pass reservations to
Travelweb (formerly known as HDS)." VIP International's client hotels
manage their inventories and rates from a customized Web screen to control
the rooms they have on the shelf in one or all of their channels. This is
the 'merchant model' of inventory control. "We know the marketplace
is complex so VIP has client representatives who actively work with our
hotels to help them understand new offerings and changes in existing
channels. " VIP International offers client hotels two payment
options; a fixed dollar amount on reservations sold, plus a monthly
service charge; or a small percent fee on each reservation and a lower
monthly service charge. The monthly charge goes toward paying the GDS and
other fees related to reservation handling between companies, and related
3rd party commissions.
Tiger's golf clubs
Mark Ozawa, vice president of
Sceptre (www.esceptre.com), a reservation services company, said,
"There is a huge amount of reservation technology available to
hotels. The problem is, you can have the best technology tools, but if you
don't know how to use them you will not benefit. If you had Tiger Woods'
golf clubs could you play as well as he does? Service is the key to using
the tools right." Sceptre is one of a group of reservation companies
that differentiates itself by offering hands-on service in addition to
channel connectivity. Sceptre uses 'Hotel Factory' technology for central
reservations and travel site connectivity. "More and more
reservations companies are using Internet-based ASP (application service
provider) utilities to allow client hotels to change availability on open
room blocks and keep rates current. Sceptre, like many reservations
providers, uses its Web site to let hotels open and close blocks and
update rates, and then puts their changes out real-time to all the
channels, including the GDSes," continued Ozawa. Fees for services
vary by reservation company, and often on a case-by-case basis depending
on the number of reservations a property is expected to receive. Sceptre
provides marketing and connectivity services for a monthly service charge
and a per-transaction fee based on consumption, not production. The
difference is that client properties pay Sceptre for reservations booked
when the guest checks out. With a production-fee structure properties pay
reservation companies when a reservation is booked. One advantage of the
consumption method is that cancellations do not require a fee refund or
credit, as often happens with the production method.
Net rate deals: how do they
work?
At a recent HFTP chapter meeting the
guest speaker, a well-known Atlanta travel industry figure told the
gathering, "The hospitality industry hates having to do net rate
deals." The comment deserves clarification. In recent months 'net
rate,' also called 'direct rate,' reservation channels have seen a steep
increase in sales due largely to the travel industry's continued downturn.
When a hotel sells a block of distressed (or not so distressed) room
nights to a channel marketer like Hotels.com or Expedia for resale by
them, the price paid by the marketer to the hotel is 'net,' that is, there
are no commissions, GDS, or other marketing fees applied; the fees, and
further marketing costs, are paid by the channel reseller. The hotel makes
a smaller amount of gross revenue on the room, but has no fees to pay, and
is usually grateful to sell off the block and get the business in the
lobby. Eleven year-old Hotels.com with 7,000 participating hotels is the
most successful net-rate channel marketer. It is publicly traded [NASDAQ:
ROOM] with a market cap of over $900M. Once Hotels.com has a block of
rooms from a client hotel it is motivated to sell those rooms at the
highest possible rate because Hotels.com makes its margin on the spread
between the rate at which they sell, and the net rate it paid for the
rooms. Hotels.com keeps the difference and there are no commissions or
other fees charged to client properties.
Bob Diener, Hotels.com's president,
said, "Most hotels could not afford the several hundred million
dollars we invest annually in direct marketing to sell their hotel rooms.
We build entire Web sites for our hotel partners, including photos and
complete property descriptions to promote their rooms to over 29,000 of
our affiliates. We also send out over three million emails every week to
our clients, and operate four call centers in the US and Europe." The
result is over eight million room-nights sold in 250 cities this year.
Hotels.com sells rooms steadily year round and assists hotels in moving
inventory, especially during slow periods "Hotels.com sells primarily
to the leisure market, and guests prepay Hotels.com for their room. When
Hotels.com sells a room we immediately provide the hotel with notification
and the reservation information. For many properties Hotels.com is the
difference between making a profit and showing a loss," said Diener.
Hotels.com is part of USA Interactive, which also owns Expedia and
Ticketron.
Automation explanation
Many reservation companies have
taken advantage of new remote processing technology to convert their
services to client-controlled ASP functionality. This is still the
'merchant model' of inventory and rate control that allows hotels to
access their own available room blocks via the Internet to close or open
individual channels, or even to update their hotel's description when
amenities are added or removed. Unirez Inc. (www.unirez.com) developed the
Hotel Factory central reservation technology that allows its 2,700 hotels
to offer rooms to the GDSes and to many other channels through their ASP
system. Hotels can use Unirez Web services to develop entirely new
packages or room types, and have their modifications immediately uploaded
to all the appropriate channels. Clients can even offer different rates to
different channels, so Sabre may be showing different rates than Apollo.
Unirez also maintains its own large voice center that handles over three
million calls a year and powers two other centers with its Hotel Factory
technology. "Our goal is to have a paperless operation," said
Rodney Wise, Unirez COO. "Our hotels control their own inventory and
rates. Property managers make the changes they want to implement their
company's sales strategies; we provide the distribution technology for
their action." Unirez assesses fees on production so, depending on
the property, charges can be a flat fee per room booked, or a percentage
of revenue.
Charges for voice center services
are on both a per-call basis, and for reservations booked. The per-call
voice center fee is customary because many of the calls handled are for
reservation changes, cancellations, or are informational without the
possibility of converting the call to a reservation. When voice centers
publish their 'conversion rate' they are stating the percentage of
incoming calls their agents convert to booked reservations.
Synxis is another company with its
own technology to allow hoteliers to control their channel placement and
inventory. "There are so many points of distribution the average
hotelier needs a distribution manager to make most systems work,"
said Carol Levitt, Synxis' director of marketing and communications.
"On their own, hotel managers often fall back on what they know,
selling rooms through call centers and only dolling out small blocks to
familiar channels. This leaves the tremendous potential of Internet sales
underutilized." Synxis gives their new client hotels a 'Welcome Kit'
that explains channels and options to shorten the learning curve for
first-time Internet channel users. They also train clients on how to use
the distribution system and maintain their own accounts on line. Hotels
pay Synxis when reservations are booked through the Synxis system. If a
reservation is cancelled, hotels receive a credit for the fees. Synxis
pays the GDS-related charges. Synxis is in the enviable position of
controlling about 80 percent of the rooms inventory of Las Vegas, a market
whose guests like to use the Internet.
Nothing happens until someone
sells something
While many representation companies
stress the service they provide, others underline the fact that rooms sold
and revenue generated are the final measures of a successful reservations
and representation company. Utell is a subsidiary of Pegasus Solutions,
but operates as a customer of Pegasus using Pegasus products. Pegasus is
in the business of providing travel Web sites and GDSes with hotel
inventory to sell. It is important to note before we go further that only
Pegasus and Wizcom can connect hotels to the GDSes (Amadeus, Sabre,
Worldspan, and Galileo), all other firms are 'representation companies'
that connect through Pegasus or Wizcom.
Utell, the largest international
hotel reservations and representation company, has more than 50 sales
people that promote its more than 5,000 member hotels to travel agents and
corporate travel managers. Utell maintains its own 'Great Rates'
room-pricing program to make room rates simpler for its hotel members.
Hotels give Utell the rates they want to promote, and Utell works across
all rate categories with nine voice reservation centers, GDS connectivity,
toll-free numbers, and Utell.com connects to over a thousand sites that
sell travel arrangements. Utell also provides clients with an Internet
utility called NetRez that allows hotels to update inventories and rates
on-line 24 hours a day. Utell is so large that several major chains use
its voice centers, which also provide services to 41 countries. Travel
agents in South Korea, for example, dial Utell voice agents directly to
book hotel reservations throughout the US or in 160 other countries.
Service and representation levels determine Utell's fee structure, but a
monthly fee and percentage of room transactions are customary, motivating
Utell agents motivated to up-sell. Up selling is good for properties, even
if the margin goes into the selling company's pockets. The higher the rate
charged the better; not only for the selling company, but also for the
hotel's stature and future marketing efforts.
InnLink, with over 700 client hotels
and its own 100-agent voice center, uses Wizcom's seamless GDS connection
for outbound distribution of its rooms inventory. "A seamless GDS
connection means that a property's rates and availability are always
current and reliable," said Mike Otten, Innlink's sales and marketing
director. "Travel agents target hotels and reservation companies that
employ seamless connectivity because they are confident in the hotel
availability data and in the rate presentation." All travel agents
and Internet subscribers who access Pegasus rooms content may see
InnLink's hotels. InnLink offers hotels custom reporting and operates its
own call center with sales agents trained to process group reservations,
an uncommon advantage in the reservation services business. InnLink's
sales agents work with properties to process group master information
including dates and rates, and processed over eight million dollars in
group reservations year to date.
Lexington Services, the largest
domestic reservation provider, uses the Spirit central reservation system,
and Pegasus GDS connectivity. The company recently added its LexLink
Internet management tool for its client hotels allowing them to control
their inventory 24/7 for all channels. Lexington specializes in prominent
mid-scale independent hotels, resorts and chains. The company prides
itself on providing a 'one-stop-shop' for Expedia, Travelweb, and all
independent sites at once, and operates a large voice and support center
in Dallas where its headquarters are located.
On the horizon
The economic downturn is forcing
many hotels to enter into 'net-rate' programs with companies like
Hotels.com, Expedia, Travelocity and others, where properties sell large
room blocks at low rates to maintain cash flow. This is a good thing for
many hotels today, but times will change. A stronger market will motivate
hotels to refrain from using discounted channels and opt for sales
strategies that yield a higher rate, causing net-rate companies to lose
market share.
A second attack on some net-rate and
other reservation providers is being made by Travelweb LLC (formerly Hotel
Distribution System, LLC) formed by Hilton Hotels Corporation, Hyatt,
Marriott International, Six Continents Hotels Corporation, Starwood Hotels
and Resorts, and Pegasus Solutions. The six companies created Travelweb to
preserve chain rate integrity and brand identity in the face of
uncontrolled, discount-driven price erosion. "Travelweb is in
business to help hotels maintain their brand identity in the face of
on-line distributors that would turn hotel rooms into a lowest-price
commodity," explained Joe Humphry, CEO of Travelweb. "We do that
through our Pegasus reservation interface which allows Travelweb to access
our client hotels' reservation systems in real time so all their inventory
is accurate when we sell rooms. Additionally, we enable hotels to yield
manage the rooms we sell, and provide guests with hotel-generated
confirmation numbers to ensure their booking information is accurate and
the brand is represented. Many of the other reservation service providers
only offer their own confirmation numbers, which often results in
confusion at check-in. Another advantage Travelweb offers is the ability
to pay our clients every 30 days on average for rooms sold."
Learn to use the tools
For hotel operators who want to
broaden their rooms distribution intelligently there are a number of
channel service providers ready to help. Fees, service options, and
technology vary by company, and many offer on-line tools that let hotels
control their own rates and room blocks. The hands-on merchant model of
channel room control goes a long way toward lifting the fear many
operators have about losing control of how and where their rooms are being
sold. To save clients time, several channel marketing companies offer
detailed reporting that eliminates the need for on-property paper trails.
The reservation industry is heavily
fragmented and in many cases hotels are forced to monitor rates,
inventories and channel relationships manually. The greater problem is
that this fragmentation and extra work does nothing to increase travel or
improve business. The same number of people travel to San Francisco each
week regardless of how many channels there are. The fact that Priceline,
Orbitz, Site 59, and Expedia each offer a new rate program every week does
not help the industry. What this marketing and rate proliferation does is
add more complexity to the already impossible maze of channel options.
The tangle of reservation channels
is not likely to be simplified soon. But on one level -- the easy
accessibility of hotel reservations on the Internet -- the system is
working. Hotel operators only need to learn how to use distribution
options profitably.
Michael Squires is president
of Softscribe
Inc., a consulting corporation that helps clients sell
technology products to the hospitality industry.
Source:
Hotelmarketing.com
Singapore: Tourism task force pushes for casinos
Services panel
chief rejects idea; proposal put forward to govt
The Business Times -
Will Singapore shed its squeaky-clean image and allow casinos to
operate in the country? It may, if a proposal by a government-appointed
task force wins approval.
Businessmen
say the Tourism Working Group (TWG), which is part of the Economic Review
Committee, has done the unthinkable - it has asked that casinos be
legitimised in Singapore.
Calls
for casinos were first made during the recession of 1985/86 and have
surfaced each time the economy runs into trouble. But none has gone beyond
the talking stage, as it's widely assumed the government would never allow
it. This is the first time a formal proposal has been put to the
government. Talk in business circles is that the TWG submitted its
proposal some months ago and is awaiting a decision.
Contacted
by BT, TWG chairman Wee Ee Chao declined comment. Mr Wee is chairman of
the Singapore Tourism Board. He is also head of stockbroker UOB Kay Hian
and second son of United Overseas Bank chairman Wee Cho Yaw.
The
TWG is part of the sub-committee for service industries which reports to
the Economic Review Committee appointed by the government to 'remake'
Singapore's economy.
In
September, the TWG unveiled a comprehensive report to double annual
tourist arrivals to 15 million and tourism receipts to $20 billion within
10 years. Its proposals ranged from sprucing up Orchard Road to joint
marketing with other countries in Asia. But there was no mention of
casinos. Instead, the TWG is said to have prepared a separate proposal on
the pros and cons and submitted it directly to the government. 'Every one
is playing it low. It's a very emotional issue,' said a hotel and property
owner.
Few
issues divide Singaporeans as casinos do. The 'no to casinos' camp - said
to include a number of cabinet ministers, particularly those old enough to
remember the back-alley casinos in Singapore's early days - is worried
about the adverse social effects on the population, especially the young.
One
vocal critic is Khaw Boon Wan, Senior Minister of State for Transport and
Information, Communications & the Arts, and chairman of the ERC
subcommittee on services, to which the TWG belonged.
Mr
Khaw was said to have refused to sign the TWG report if it included any
mention of casinos. This is why the TWG submitted a separate proposal.
In
an email yesterday, Mr Khaw told BT: 'Some industry players are keen (on
casinos), but I don't think it's a good idea. I won't support it myself.
The social impact of casinos cannot be simply brushed aside. We cannot
prevent people from gambling, but to glamorise gambling is a different
matter altogether.'
He
said countries like Canada and Australia are regretting allowing casinos,
and 'if allowing casino is the only way to re-energise our tourism
industry, then it's a truly sad day for our tourism industry! I like to
believe that tourists come to Singapore for better reasons than that.' The
TWG, however, is said to have considered casinos 'purely on business
grounds', and the realisation that it's the only way to double tourism
receipts in 10 years.
'All
other (TWG) proposals are not new. You can throw a lot of money in
infrastructure and you can talk about regional cooperation, but you can't
make people come here unless they want to come here. And gambling is the
only way to do it,' said an industry player.
According
to this 'yes to casinos' camp, gambling is already legitimised in many
ways in Singapore - 4-digit lottery, the Big Sweep, horse racing and
betting on the 2002 World Cup, which raked in $500 million revenues for
the government-owned Singapore Pools.
To
them, casinos are just another way for Singaporeans to gamble
legitimately. Moreoever, Singaporeans are going in droves to gamble on
Star Cruise ships, and hundreds of millions of dollars flow out of the
country every year this way.
'The
government might as well set up casinos and keep the revenue at home,'
said a developer.
In
recent years, many Asian countries have opened the doors to casinos to
bring in tourist dollars. From Malaysia, the pioneer, the list now extends
to Vietnam and Myanmar.
On
Monday, Thai premier Thaksin Shinawatra met J Terrance Lanni, chairman of
MGM Mirage, the company that controls half of Las Vegas' high-end gambling
business. Mr Lanni said he is keen to invest in Thailand casino complexes
that include restaurants, hotels and entertainment facilities for the
family.
If
casinos are allowed here, they will almost certainly follow the MGM model
and be situated on Sentosa. Many companies will benefit - from hotels to
tour operators, and, of course, the party or parties appointed to run the
casinos.
In
the property market, the listed government-linked CapitaLand is generally
tipped to be one, if not the only, operator if casinos are allowed. And
the biggest loser would be Star Cruise and its parent, the Genting group,
which would lose a lot of Singapore customers.
Hong
Kong's September 2002 arrivals show 30% growth
Visitor
arrivals in September 2002 totalled 1,370,279, a 30.1% increase over the
same month in 2001, the Hong Kong Tourism Board (HKTB) announced today.
This is the highest monthly growth rate recorded so far this year.
The
encouraging figure needs to be seen, however, in the context of last
year's 11 September terrorist attacks in the United States, which sent
arrivals plummeting in the second half of that month. The comparison base
is therefore relatively low.
Nevertheless,
the cumulative January to September figures confirm that the growth trend
remains very strong. Total visitor arrivals for the first nine months of
2002 now stand at 11,743,153, a 16.0% increase on the same period in 2001.
HKTB Executive Director Clara Chong said that although the September 2002
figures were very positive and in line with the healthy growth seen
throughout this year, the circumstances made it difficult to read too much
into them.
"Once
again, the terrible events in Bali have reminded us how fragile the
recovery can be," she said. "The tourism industry can no longer
afford to take anything for granted. While feedback from our worldwide
offices and trade partners suggests that so far, this latest incident is
not having too much of an impact on bookings for Hong Kong, it seems
inevitable that it will further dampen public sentiment to travel,
especially in our long-haul markets."
On
a more positive note, Ms Chong said that visitors' average length of stay
in Hong Kong had increased to 3.52 nights over the first nine months of
2002, compared with 3.05 nights for the same period in 2001. "This is
largely due to the increased number of Mainland tour groups this
year," she explained. "Up to the end of September, the average
length of stay of Mainland visitors was 4.29 nights, a significant
increase on the 3.40 nights recorded for the first three quarters of last
year. This is welcome news for tourism-related businesses."
Analysis by Markets
Mainland
China was once again the fastest growing market in September, accounting
for 593,509 visitors, a 70.5% year-on-year-increase. More than 119,000
Mainland arrivals were recorded in the last five days of September alone,
as visitors made an early start to the "Golden Week" National
Day holiday at the beginning of October.
All
other markets also showed positive growth in September. Arrivals from
South & Southeast Asia increased by 13.0% to 148,554, with India
(18,193, +26.8%) and the Philippines (25,815, +22.9%) performing
especially well. North Asia recorded 9.2% growth to 162,476 arivals, led
by Japan (130,013, +10.6%). Arrivals from Taiwan increased 10.5% to
196,415.
In
the long-haul markets, arrivals from The Americas showed sharp growth of
20.3% to 95,814, although figures for this market, more than any other,
will have been affected by the low comparison base in the wake of last
September's terrorist attacks. Arrivals from Europe, Africa & the
Middle East rose by 9.7% to 99,150, while those from Australia, New
Zealand & South Pacific grew 6.2% to 35,786.
Cumulative
figures for the first nine months of 2002 show Mainland China leading the
way with a 47.6% increase to 4,703,556 arrivals, which already surpasses
the 4.48 million recorded in the whole of 2001. Arrivals from South &
Southeast Asia are showing a 5.4% increase, followed by Europe, Africa
& the Middle East (+3.7%), Australia, New Zealand & South Pacific
(+2.0%) and The Americas (+1.6%). Only Taiwan (-1.3%) currently remains in
negative overall growth, while arrivals from North Asia are almost
identical to those of 2001.
Same-Day
Visitors
During
September 2002, 63.1% of all visitors stayed for one night or longer,
compared with 63.4% in the same month last year. The remaining 36.9%
continued to other destinations on the same day. Visitors from The
Americas (79.6%) and Australia, New Zealand & South Pacific (79.5%)
were the most likely to stay overnight, while at the other end of the
scale, only 21.9% of all visitors from Taiwan did so.
For
the first nine months of 2002 to date, 64.5% of all visitors have stayed
for one night or longer, a similar figure to the 64.6% recorded in the
same period in 2001.
Hotel
Occupancy
Average
hotel room occupancy across all categories was 82% in September, a
significant increase on the 74% achieved in September 2001 when bookings
were severely affected by the terrorist attacks in the United States. All
different categories of hotels and tourist guest houses recorded increased
occupancy, especially the top tariff (High Tariff A) hotels, which
averaged 80% occupancy compared with only 67% the previous September.
For
the first nine months of the year to date, average occupancy stands at
82%, compared with 78% in the same period of 2001.
Online
travel site Expedia to enter Asia-Pacific
(Reuters) - US online travel agent Expedia
will expand into Asia by the end of this year, with plans to operate in
three Asia-Pacific markets by March 2003, its regional chief said.
The travel giant, whose stock has risen 19 per cent
over the last two days on strong third-quarter earnings, plans to have
operations in Hong Kong, Australia and Singapore by the end of next year's
first quarter, James Vaile, vice president of Expedia Asia-Pacific, told
Reuters by phone from Sydney.
He said Expedia would launch service in its first
Asia-Pacific market by the end of this year, but would not specify which
of the three areas will lead the push adding Japan would likely be
Expedia's fourth market in the region.
He declined to give planned investment figures for
Asia.
"Twenty-nine per cent of the global internet
population is located here in Asia," Vaile said. "The online
travel market for the Asia-Pacific region is estimated at approximately
US$8.3 billion by 2004."
With an estimated US$500 million in non-US bookings for
the current year, overseas business still accounts for a relatively small
portion of Expedia's overall bookings, which totaled US$1.47 billion in
the third quarter alone.
Internationally, Expedia, a spinoff from Microsoft
MSFT.O and now majority owned by USA Interactive USAI.O , has expanded its
overseas markets to include Britain, Germany, France, Italy and the
Netherlands over the last four years.
Vaile said that like Europe, he expected the
Asia-Pacific region to require an initial period of about four years
before it moved beyond what he called an "investment" phase.
Much of that phase in Asia will be used to determine
what appeals to local consumers, together with a push to sign hotels and
airlines into supply contracts, Vaile said. Expedia now sells rooms at
about 60,000 hotels around the world.
Vaile said that one of Expedia's main rivals in the
region would be Zuji, a service operated by a group of major regional
airlines including Cathay Pacific 0293.HK and Qantas QAN.AX .
Priceline.com PCLN.O , the U.S.-based name-your-own
price online travel firm, launched its service in Hong Kong this year and
plans to bring it to other Asian markets.
As part of its go-slow approach to the region, Expedia
will sell its services in Asia initially through third-party sites and not
directly through its own site, Vaile said.
"That's what we're doing now in this market:
investing to get it right and rolling out our relevant and fitting
proposition in each market," he said.
One of the biggest challenges facing Expedia in a
broader regional Asia-Pacific expansion is language, since all its
products to date have been designed for languages that use alphabets.
Accordingly, the initial services in Hong Kong, Australia and Singapore
will all be in English, Vaile said.
"The challenge that we're faced with in rolling
out in a non-Latin based language is it requires serious re-coding or
redevelopment of our entire source code," he said.
|